The Best Pizza in Miami County

Welcome to the ultimate guide to the best pizza in Miami County! If you’re a pizza enthusiast searching for the perfect slice, you’re in for a treat. The Miami County area has a vibrant and delicious pizza scene filled with tantalizing styles, flavors, and culinary combinations that will make your mouth water.

This list is made up of some of our personal favorite local pizza places (in no certain order)! We tried to keep chains like Pizza Hut and Papa John’s off the list, even though they’re great too! We just wanted to include the places that make up the fabric of Miami County and display the amazing local pizza flavors that you can’t find anywhere else.

Related Post: Jubie’s Creamery: A Sweet Spot in Troy

From classic, cheesy goodness to bold, inventive toppings, read on because we’ve scoured the best local pizzerias to bring you a curated list of spots, from Troy to Piqua, where each bite is a little slice of heaven.

Whether you’re a lifelong local or just passing through, get ready to discover the top places that make our city’s pizza scene truly exceptional.

Is your favorite pizza place not on the list? Tell us about them in the comments and we may just add them to this article!

Best Pizza in Troy, Ohio

Troy is packed with pizza options, and locals take their favorites seriously. From thin-crust Dayton-style classics to wood-fired Neapolitan pies and giant New York–style slices, there’s a little something for everyone here. Whether you’re grabbing delivery on a busy weeknight, meeting friends downtown, or planning a family pizza night, here are the best pizza places in Troy, Ohio that locals can’t stop talking about.

Old Scratch Pizza

Address: 245 S. Market Street, Troy, OH 45373
Phone: (937) 335-7646
Website: oldscratchpizza.com
Why you should go: Why Go: Their wood-fired pies are legendary. The Hot Honey is basically a local celebrity, and in 2023 Yelp even ranked Old Scratch as one of the Top 100 Pizza Spots in the whole country. If you swing by after PorchFest or a Friday night game, expect a crowd — but trust me, it’s worth the wait.

Must Try: The Angry Beekeeper which features their delicious hot honey!

Troni Brothers Pizza

Address: 12 S. Market Street, Troy, OH 45373
Phone: (937) 335-7464
Website: tronibrotherspizzatroy.com
Why Go: If you’re craving true New York–style pizza, this is the spot. Troni Brothers serves up giant, foldable slices with that perfect balance of chewy crust and gooey cheese. It’s the kind of pizza you grab with both hands — no forks allowed — and it feels like a little taste of NYC right in downtown Troy.

Matty Q’s

Address: 1328 Archer Drive, Troy, OH 45373
Phone: (937) 552-7270
Website:mattyqs.com
Why Go: This spot is all about big flavors and a laid-back vibe. Locals rave about their specialty pies — the loaded “Matty Q Special” is a must-try. It’s the kind of place where you can grab a pizza, catch up with friends, and feel right at home.

Must-Try: The Mac N Cheese Pizza

Long Shots

Address: 2315 Troy-Sidney Road, Troy, OH 45373
Phone: (937) 335-5698
Website: longshotsoh.com
Why Go: Long Shots might be best known as a sports bar, but don’t sleep on their pizza. It’s the perfect game-day food — cheesy, loaded with toppings, and best enjoyed with a cold drink while you catch whatever’s playing on the big screens. Locals love it for casual nights out, especially when there’s a big game on.

The Best Pizza in Tipp City, Ohio

Tipp City may be small, but when it comes to pizza, this town knows how to deliver. From classic pies that hit the spot every time to neighborhood favorites with their own twist, Tipp has a few go-to places locals swear by. Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice on Main Street or ordering in for family night, here’s where to find the best pizza in Tipp City, Ohio.

Tipp City Pizza

Address: 14 E. Main Street, Tipp City, OH 4537
Phone: (937) 667-5555
Website:tippcitypizza.com
Why Go: Right in the heart of downtown Tipp, this place has that classic small-town pizzeria feel with pies that taste like pure comfort. It’s the kind of spot where you run into neighbors, grab a giant slice, and maybe even stick around to people-watch on Main Street.

Fun Fact: They also offer gluten-free pizza crust!

The Best Pizza in Piqua, Ohio

3 Joe’s Pizzeria and Trattoria

Address: 3 N. Market Street, Troy, OH 45373
Phone: (937) 335-1800
Website: 3joes.com
Why Go: 3 Joe’s is more than just pizza — it’s a full Italian experience right in the middle of downtown Troy. The wood-fired pies are fantastic, but don’t sleep on the pasta or their famous garlic knots. It’s a great spot for date night or a family dinner before hitting the square.

Crooked Handle Brewing Co. Piqua

Address: 123 N. Main Street, Piqua, OH 45356
Phone: (937) 418-2162
Website:crookedhandle.com
Why Go: Crooked Handle might be known for their craft beer, but locals know the pizza is just as good. Think crispy crust, creative toppings, and the perfect pint to go with it. It’s one of those places where you can hang with friends, listen to live music, and still say, “yep, I came here for the pizza.”

Marion’s Piazza

Address: 1270 Experiment Farm Road, Troy, OH 45373
Phone: (937) 339-2000
Website:marionspiazza.com
Why Go: Marion’s is a Dayton legend, and thankfully we’ve got one right here in Troy. The thin-crust, square-cut pizzas are what everyone comes for, but don’t overlook their giant party-size pies — perfect for feeding a whole team after a game. If you grew up in the Miami Valley, there’s a good chance you had your first pizza party at Marion’s.

FAQ: Best Pizza in Miami County

What’s the most popular pizza place in Miami County?

Old Scratch in Troy has gotten national attention (Yelp’s Top 100 in the U.S.), but locally, you’ll also hear Marion’s and 3 Joe’s come up again and again.

Do any pizza places deliver?

Yes! Most of the local spots offer delivery through DoorDash, UberEats, or their own system. If you’re in Troy, Ron’s and 3 Joe’s both deliver. In Piqua, Casanova’s and Caveman Pizza are go-tos.

Who makes the best pizza for kids’ parties?

Tipp City Pizza has party rooms upstairs you can rent out for parties and includes duck pin bowling.

What’s the best pizza for date night?

3 Joe’s in Piqua has that cozy trattoria vibe, and Crooked Handle pairs pizza with craft beer and music at Lock 9 — great for a fun, casual night out.

Do any spots have gluten-free pizza?

Yes! Old Scratch offers a gluten-free crust, and several local places will make one by request. Always check the menu first to be safe.

That’s a wrap on Miami County’s best pizza! Whether you’re team thin-crust squares from Marion’s, obsessed with Old Scratch’s Hot Honey, or loyal to your small-town favorite, one thing’s for sure — we’re pretty spoiled for good pizza around here.

The truth is, the “best” pizza really depends on your mood. Big group? Head to Marion’s. Date night? 3 Joe’s. After a game? Ron’s or Matty Q’s. Just want a quick slice before PorchFest? Old Scratch has you covered.

Now I want to hear from you — who did I miss? Send me a message on Instagram @MiamiCountyLive or drop your pick in the comments. Because if there’s one thing I know about Miami County, it’s that we’ll never stop debating where to grab the perfect slice.