If you’re hungry in Troy, pizza is always the answer. The only problem? Deciding where to go. This city is loaded with great options — from wood-fired Neapolitan pies to classic Dayton-style squares and giant New York slices you can barely fold. I’ve eaten my way through town (for research, of course), and I’m here to give you the inside scoop on the best pizza in Troy, Ohio.
Old Scratch Pizza
Address: 245 S. Market Street, Troy, OH 45373
Phone: (937) 335-7646
Website: oldscratchpizza.com
Old Scratch isn’t just a local favorite — it’s a national one. In 2023, Yelp ranked it among the Top 100 Pizza Spots in the U.S., and one bite of their Hot Honey pizza will tell you why. The crust is wood-fired to perfection, the toppings are bold, and the vibe is modern and lively. If you go on a weekend or after PorchFest, expect a wait — but trust me, it’s worth it.
Troni Brothers
Address: 12 S. Market Street, Troy, OH 45373
Phone: (937) 335-7464
Website: tronibrotherspizzatroy.com
If you’re craving New York–style pizza, Troni Brothers is the real deal. We’re talking giant, foldable slices with gooey cheese and that chewy crust that makes you want another bite before you’ve even finished the first. It’s no-frills, all flavor — and a must if you like your pizza big and bold.
Marion’s Piazza
Address: 1270 Experiment Farm Road, Troy, OH 45373
Phone: (937) 339-2000
Website: marionspiazza.com
Marion’s is a Dayton institution, and thankfully we’ve got one here in Troy. Their thin-crust, square-cut pizza is iconic — the kind of pie you either grew up on or will instantly fall in love with. It’s the ultimate party pizza, especially when you order one of their giant trays. For big groups, Marion’s can’t be beat.
Matty Q’s Pizza
Address: 1328 Archer Drive, Troy, OH 45373
Phone: (937) 552-7270
Website: mattyqspizza.com
Matty Q’s is newer to the scene but already has a loyal following. Their specialty pizzas are stacked with toppings, and the atmosphere is casual and fun — perfect for a weeknight dinner or catching up with friends. The “Matty Q Special” is a local favorite if you can’t decide what to order.
Long Shots
Address: 2315 Troy-Sidney Road, Troy, OH 45373
Phone: (937) 335-5698
Website: longshotsohio.com
Known as a sports bar first, Long Shots also turns out seriously good pizza. Cheesy, shareable, and best with a cold beer, it’s the kind of pie you want on game day. With plenty of big screens and a lively atmosphere, this is where pizza and sports come together in the best way.
Staunton Country Store Pizza
Address: 2310 N. State Route 202, Troy, OH 45373
Phone: (937) 339-1284
Website: N/A
If you know, you know. Staunton Country Store looks like a simple little market, but inside they’re turning out some of the most underrated pizza in Troy. It’s takeout only, the toppings are piled high, and the crust has that just-right chew that keeps locals coming back. This is true hidden-gem pizza — the kind of place you only find out about from a friend.
Troy Ohio Pizza FAQ
What’s the most popular pizza in Troy?
Old Scratch’s Hot Honey and Marion’s classic thin-crust are both local legends.
Who delivers pizza in Troy, Ohio?
Matty Q’s plus most spots are on DoorDash or UberEats
Where’s the best pizza for a date night?
Old Scratch is fun and modern with craft beer and great cocktails.
What about big groups?
Marion’s and Old Scratch both have party rooms.
Final Slice
That’s the Troy pizza lineup — the places locals actually eat at and argue about. From national shoutouts at Old Scratch to the hometown classics like Marion’s, Troy’s pizza scene is a mix of old-school comfort and new flavors.
So, what’s your favorite? Did I miss your go-to spot? Tell me in the comments or send me a message on Instagram @MiamiCountyLive — I love discovering new local favorites.
Because if there’s one thing I know for sure, it’s this: pizza in Troy is more than food, it’s tradition.
Want to see how Troy stacks up to Miami County in the pizza department? Check out our Miami County Pizza Guide here.
