When Old Scratch Pizza opened its doors in Troy, it didn’t take long for locals to fall in love. If you’ve driven past on a Friday night, you’ve probably seen the crowd — families, groups of friends, and couples all gathering around big tables with a slice (or two) in hand. This isn’t just another pizza place. Old Scratch has earned a reputation as one of the best spots in Troy, and with good reason.
Related Post: The Best Pizza in Troy, Ohio
What Makes Old Scratch Pizza Special
First things first: the pizza. Old Scratch specializes in Neapolitan-style, wood-fired pies that are cooked hot and fast, giving you that perfect chewy crust with a little char. Their most famous creation, the Bee Keeper pizza is practically a local celebrity. Sweet, spicy, cheesy — it’s a flavor combo that wins people over instantly.
Other favorites include the Salsiccia (sausage, peppers, onion) and the rotating seasonal pies that keep the menu feeling fresh. And while pizza is the star, the wings, salads, and craft beer list are just as impressive.
In 2023, Yelp named Old Scratch one of the Top 100 Pizza Spots in the U.S., putting Troy on the national food map. Not bad for our little corner of Ohio.
Atmosphere
Part of what makes Old Scratch such a hit is the vibe. Think modern industrial meets family-friendly hangout. The space is open and lively, with long communal tables where you can sit down with your crew (or end up making new friends). It’s casual enough for a weeknight dinner, but fun enough to make it a Friday night tradition.
Kids love watching the pizzas go into the giant wood-fired ovens, and adults appreciate the rotating list of craft beers on tap. It’s the kind of place where everyone feels comfortable — whether you’re in bike gear after a ride, or dressed up a little for date night.
Location, Hours & Contact
Address: 245 S. Market Street, Troy, OH 45373
Phone: (937) 335-7646
Website: oldscratchpizza.com
Hours: Typically open daily for lunch and dinner (check the website for updated hours).
Parking is available nearby, but weekends can be busy — arrive early if you want to avoid the rush.
Why Locals Love It
Old Scratch is one of those places that feels like part of Troy now. It’s where people head after PorchFest, where families meet up after Friday night football, and where friends grab a beer and split a pizza just because.
The food is consistent, the staff is friendly, and the experience is one you’ll want to repeat. It’s casual enough for everyday dining, but the quality is high enough to make it feel like a treat.
Pro Tips
- Try the Bee Keeper Pizza at least once — even if you don’t think you like sweet + spicy.
- Weekends get busy. If you don’t want to wait, aim for lunch or an early dinner.
- Pair your pizza with one of their local craft beers — they keep the tap list fresh.
- Gluten-free crust is available, but call ahead to confirm.
- Don’t skip the Roasted Cauliflower. Trust me.
FAQ: Old Scratch Pizza Troy
Does Old Scratch Pizza take reservations?
No, it’s first-come, first-served. But the large space helps keep things moving.
Does Old Scratch Pizza deliver?
Delivery is available through DoorDash and similar services, but dine-in is where you’ll get the full experience.
Is Old Scratch family-friendly?
Absolutely. Big tables, fast service, and a fun atmosphere make it perfect for families with kids.
What’s the most popular pizza?
The Bee Keeper is hands-down the fan favorite.
Related Local Spots
Already downtown? Make a night of it and listen to one of the concerts on Prouty or stop by one of the amazing local stores and boutiques.
Old Scratch is one of our favorite spots and has been featured in several articles including:
